Skip to Search Skip to Live Player Skip to Content Skip to Footer

Would You Buy a Known Haunted House to Save Money?

Author Joe Winner
The Amityville Horror house rich history and beauty are overshadowed by the story of George and Kathy Lutz, the previous residents of 112 Ocean Avenue, who claimed that shortly after moving into the house they fled in terror driven out by paranormal activity. The best selling novel and popular movie have marked the town as the site of the most famous haunted house in history, yet many are unaware that the true history of this house is much darker than "The Amityville Horror's" icy drafts and bleeding walls. Six members of the DeFeo family were murdered at 112 Ocean Avenue one year before the Lutz family moved in and their tragedy haunts the citizens of Amityville to this day. (Photo by Paul Hawthorne/Getty Images)

Housing prices in Southwest Florida show no signs of letting up. I was just writing earlier that our home price values are projected to continue to increase at a rate greater than inflation well into next year.  So how is anyone here supposed to be able to afford to buy a home? So I was thinking – what if the house was haunted. Would you be willing to buy, and move into a house, that you knew was haunted? Are there any? Is there a known haunted house for sale in Florida?

The answer is yes, to save money, 63% would offer below market value on a haunted house. 

More than 1 in 4 Americans (29%) believe they’ve actually lived in a haunted house — up from 24% in 2022, according to new research from Real Estate Witch. Of those who have lived in a haunted house, 73% were not aware of its paranormal reputation prior to moving in. Unsurprisingly, 40% of those who knowingly bought a haunted house were swayed due to a lower price tag.

What would convince you to buy a haunted house?

What would convince you to buy a haunted house?

Despite the cost savings, 36% of haunted homeowners regret living in a haunted house.

55% would not buy another home they knew was haunted.

Although buying a haunted house in Florida, or anywhere, would make people uneasy, more than half (52%) remain open to the idea. 71% would consider it if they could save money.

Most Americans (62%) would only offer below market value for a haunted home.  1 in 3 (31%) offering at least $50,000 less. Notably, 48% say nothing could convince them to purchase a haunted house.

So, let’s take a look at what you can get. Here’s a house for sale in Pensacola for $1.19 million that’s reportedly haunted. It’s a beautiful house, but in hindsight you really should have researched that location. It was built in 1900 on the site of a Revolutionary War battlefield.

 

52 W Gonzalez St

Matterport 3D Showcase.

In the realtor’s defense, they do disclose “Caution, ghosts included!”

So – could you buy a known haunted house if it meant you could save some money?

I mean, check out some of these places in Naples and tell me at least one of them isn’t haunted.

Naples Florida Single Family Homes You Can Buy For Less Than $300,000

  • 1975 Everglades Blvd S, - $250,000

    This place reminds me of the shack where Ray Finkle grew up in rural Collier County. It does come with over 2 1/2 acres. There are other houses in the area so I’m assuming there’s utilities. This lovely single family home was built in 1984 making me really wonder how it has survived all the hurricanes that have been through here since then. Just a few blocks down from Palmetto Elementary it might be a place to start a family. Plan for some 14 mile trips to the nearest hardware store as it appears this is a bit of a ‘fixer upper’.

    https://www.realtor.com/realestateandhomes-detail/1975-Everglades-Blvd-S_Naples_FL_34117_M60074-80207?from=srp-list-card

  • 5477 Martin St - $270,000

    This cozy 3 bed, 2 bath, 1100 square foot home located in Naples Manor is currently in foreclosure. A true handyman’s dream as the first thing you’ll need to do is replace the roof. And the ac. And try to figure out just what was going on in that bathroom. As a bonus, there’s no neighbors adjacent on the back of the house so the kids will have room to play. Once you remove all the debris, of course.

    5477 Martin St, Naples, FL 34113 | realtor.com®

    View 31 photos for 5477 Martin St, Naples, FL 34113, a 3 bed, 2 bath, 1,100 Sq. Ft. single family home built in 1977 that was last sold on 10/13/2023.

  • 117 Audubon Rd - $275,000

    To start, this is in a 55+ community so that knocks out the starter home idea. But other than that, this place really doesn’t look too bad. A 2 bedroom, 2 bath, with docks and gulf access. HOA just $16 a month. I’m actually fans of the current residents because, as the pictures show, they clearly hate furniture. When there’s no couches or tables there’s so much more room for activities. We could make bunk beds!

    117 Audubon Rd, Naples, FL 34114 | realtor.com®

    See photos and price history of this 2 bed, 2 bath, 1,292 Sq. Ft. recently sold home located at 117 Audubon Rd, Naples, FL 34114 that was sold on 12/14/2023 for $260000.

  • 2364 Bayside St - $275,000

    Is this a house or a shed? I think it may actually be a shed. This biggest selling point, as the realtor noted in all caps “NO HOA FEES OR RESTRICTIONS”. So, do whatever you want. The front door appears to be boarded, so it’s possible that the furniture comes with. That couch looks like it has stories. 

    2364 Bayside St, Naples, FL 34112 | realtor.com®

    2364 Bayside St, Naples, FL 34112 is for sale. View 19 photos of this 2 bed, 1 bath, 414 sqft. single family home with a list price of $249900.

  • 46 Lanai Ct - $299,900

    Your last choice hits the upper range of our $300,000 limit. Located in Lely Tropical Estates this 2 bed/2 bath 915 square foot home looks well maintained. Aside from some questionable judgment on decor, this might be the best of the bunch. 

    46 Lanai Ct, Naples, FL 34112 | realtor.com®

    View detailed information about property 46 Lanai Ct, Naples, FL 34112 including listing details, property photos, school and neighborhood data, and much more.

  • And that's it.

    If you’re looking to move into a single family home in Naples with a $300,000 budget, those are your options. Don’t forget to also budget in the near 8% mortgage interest rate, which certainly eats into purchasing power.

    I spoke with my neighbor about this yesterday. How can we really expect working class people to move here when they can’t afford to live? The solution used to be, live in Lehigh and drive to work. But even Lehigh Acres is getting too expensive for regular people. And making everyone drive long commutes to work just further crowds our roads. What’s the answer?

Joe Winner spends his days combing through memes and off beat stories to bring you the side of Florida not always seen.

Sign me up for the 96k Rock email newsletter!

K-Rock Stan and Haney VIP Club members get tons of extra perks: Exclusive pre-sales, Invites to Meet & Greets, Amazing offers and more. It’s simple to sign up and start raking in all the rewards.

*
*
By clicking "Subscribe" I agree to the website's terms of Service and Privacy Policy. I understand I can unsubscribe at any time.
Author Joe Winner
Category:
Tags:
,,

More Trending Locally

Load More